Bethany Bullman 3B
Bethany Bullman 3A
Emma Price 3C
Laura-May Houghton 3B
Natalie Martin 3A (Beth's question)
Natalie Martin 3A
Carla L Mason 3C
Anna Timms 3C
Melanie Brown 3C
Megan Lewis 3B
Above are all the blogs that have inspired some of my ideas or have made me question my own practice. I have commented on each of these providing my reasons for their inspiration and any critical thinking.
Below is a spider diagram from my journal (of which I got the idea from Natalie Martin's blog above) to help me to reflect and raise any critical questions:
I do apologize for the scribbly-ness and blurry-ness of it, but I was lacking a bit of room, and I couldn't keep my hand steady.
The first question that emerged was about my job sites. Most people have written about 'The stage' and 'agents' etc being some of their important resources. Like I've commented on Natalie Martin's blog, referring to a question by Bethany Bullman, (see above Beth's question) The Stage for me is TES or Indeed.com. But the question that I ask myself is; do I check up on my automated emails that offer new job opportunities from TES and Indeed.com? Well actually I don't. I hardly ever open these emails. Why? Because one, I haven't updated the line of work that I wish to receive opportunities for. Right now, both of these sites are sending me 'Assistant teacher' and 'Retail assistant' positions. Because of this, two, I struggle to find the time to change them. Which raises the next question; are my priorities in the right place? I believe that I do have most of my priorities straight and correct, but one that isn't is within my job. I work as a dance/performing arts teacher at the weekends, but as a retail assistant within the week. I do not wish to work in retail any more, but I am very bad at helping myself. So this is a big realization. I must organize my day and to prioritize my job searching, heading in the direction that I wish to be going.
What is Twinkl? To begin with, I thought this site would be right up my alley, from Bethany Bullman's task 3A. So I went on to google and had a check. It would be a wonderful site if I were focused on teaching in Primary schools. My aim is to teach in Junior and Senior schools. Saying this, I do not know what the future holds. I cannot be small minded and just brush this new resource out of the window. I can either keep it at hand, as if it were part of a network; it could be very valuable some day, or I can sweep it out of the door and forget about it. This is a knowledge that I probably never would have received without participating in the BAPP course. It also proves what sources are out there from just keeping in the know of other people.
My next question is; have I been fully engaged on part 3 in the BAPP course? I have been extremely engaged on this part. I have made extra effort in finding other potentially useful blogs, because I have come to realize how vital this can be, and I have printed out the Reading list extracts and have highlighted what I believe to be the most important. It has been a really intriguing part of Module 1, particularly task 3B which includes cultural differences within the concept of Affiliation. I'm gradually starting to use my professional networks in a more profound way to help myself. Some of this is proven in the comments on blogs, and the ideas that I've gotten from them. My cooperation skills with my teaching colleague has improved greatly, just by being more aware of how we cooperate.
I thought I'd use the question provided in the handbook, outright, for my next part; Are your ideas, position or concerns shared by others within and/or beyond your professional area of work?
As you can just about see in my spider diagram, I asked the question of whether or not I should ask my best friend about her work with younger children. I should, as we share a similar position within my area of work. We both work with children. So, I actually do not know the answer to whether we share the same ideas or concerns, which is something I will work towards, but I know that we share a similar position.
In Bethany Bullman's task 3B, she spoke about status' within a school, and how it depends on that status as to whom you cooperate with. I commented on this as I share similar views on this. I find it a real shame that the system works this way, because everybody can learn a thing or two on anything, of which can be either practical for you or really not that useful at all, but there is always the possibilities. My boss does the same job as everybody else at the centre that I work at, but she obviously has those important things on top of that which makes her job more superior. It's very hard to ask her for advice, especially as she hired me, and I would assume that she would expect me to learn and grow as a teacher by myself from experience. But what I've learned from this course, is that you learn from experience, of course, but we also learn from others' experiences. Some people choose not to, and end up learning from their own experience, but sometimes it's easier to bypass any mistakes that you may make, and learn from others instead. Why don't we? Because we don't believe it would happen to us right? This is something the BAPP course has taught me very efficiently. Learn from others as well as yourself.
Of course my family, (as I've revealed before, are all teachers) is mentioned in the spider diagram. Do they share the same ideas and concerns? Absolutely. I share with my mother all the time about issues and concerns in my teaching. I give her my ideas, and she gives me advice on how to improve them. This then raised the question; should I contact my other family members more? I know that I don't contact my brother and sister enough. Unlike my mother, they both have experience in performing arts as well as music and teaching. Seeing as it's performing arts that I am teaching, why haven't I contacted them more? Affiliating with my family is hard living so far away from each other, but like in the previous tasks, we now have resources and other methods of communication other than just meeting up and sending letters in the post. Referring to Melanie Browns' task 3C (see above), she does share similar views on mobile phones. They are so vital in any career, for keeping up with the times, keeping in touch with important networks and receiving new job positions etc. Mobile phones are a great way to affiliate nowadays, even though I feel it can prevent people from actually affiliating properly by meeting up, which I think being face to face is far more uplifting and beneficial. So, to add to my learning, whenever I feel the need for help within my teaching, I will now make the effort to contact my brother or sister about it, as well as my mother.
Also referring to Melanie Brown's task 3C, it made me bring up the idea about how useful online resources is for the much older generation. Elderly people are so vulnerable and the internet gives the benefits of grocery shopping online. This may have adapted so much by the time we are at that very fragile age, and these sources may be even easier in the future. I have been very negative about technology, especially as I believe it makes people lazy, but this sharing and communicating with others has shifted my thinking which makes me less ignorant and makes me think on a wider scale. Sure it can make the younger generation lazy, but it's less effort for the elderly which I haven't thought into much at all. We see all younger generations on smartphones and tablets etc, everywhere, but what you don't see are the elder generations using their laptops and ipads behind their closed doors. Ipads, tablets and smartphones are pretty useless for the very young generation, and I think it's a real shame that some parents buy them for their three year olds. This also shifts my thinking just by sharing to you now. Experience. Children don't experience things anymore because they are glued to their tablets playing games. Objects and day outs I believe are vital as they offer a better knowledge and gives them experience, as most children learn by doing and seeing.
As I go along with this, and sharing these ideas with you, it also now makes me want to put these ideas in to my professional practice in some way. Seeing as I work with the younger generation, and keeping in mind that they learn from doing and seeing, I need to adapt some sort of learning activities into my dance and music classes with them. I also must exaggerate every dance move and rhythm game. Just from sharing, I have come up with ideas.
Does critical reflection help you decide what really matters and the actions to take? Absolutely! Just from reflecting on my Affiliation in the past, particularly in my working relationships in Israel, I know the reasons why I was so lonely. (See my Task 3B) here I said; "I'm definitely more extrovert on a more personal level, but introvert on a not so personal level". This proves to me why I didn't feel the need to affiliate with my fellow performers, but the downside to this was that I did become lonely and very homesick as my extrovert self missed the people who I felt close to. I also said; "on a professional level, being that bit more extrovert deliberately, would prove to be very useful in any career." I'm now not only thinking how useful it can be on a professional level, like I've mentioned in this post, but also on an emotional level. Hence, from my critical reflection and new knowledge on affiliation I do make more of an effort to be more extrovert even if it doesn't feel comfortable to begin with.
Another way in which critical reflection helps me to decide what actions to take is from Cooperation. Looking back at particular situations where cooperation was involved and competing when working together and not, competing only seemed to work well in competitions when you were to perform a solo. Pretty obvious really. But, cooperating when competing in a duet, trio or troupe performance was vital. If you constantly competed within a dance troupe against your fellow performers it would look messy. I always use to try and kick my leg the highest in a dance duet, trio or troupe. When I critically reflect on this, I ask myself; why did I do this? Because I wasn't cooperating. I was thinking of myself and was competing. (I'm sure many of us have similar experiences of trying to look better than the other dancers). By doing this, the dance trio, duet or troupe wouldn't look very neat and would never get a gold medal. Saying this, even in a solo performance, I had to cooperate with my teacher. She knows best. (again my Task 3B gives my understanding on cooperation) This doesn't mean to say that cooperation doesn't have competition. You cooperate to be a great competitor.
Relating to all of the last few paragraphs, affiliation assists my thinking on my professional networks the most. Second to this is cooperation. One thing that I haven't mentioned is Communities of practice. Thinking about Twinkl, of which I mentioned earlier, this is a community, and it can be a source for practice. Wenger identifies a community of practice as a "mutual engagement that bind members together into a social entity." (Reader 3, p9) It's a community to share ideas and debate. Even though I don't feel that Twinkl is for me, this concept has got me thinking and I've asked myself is there a community that I can join that would suit my professional networking? There must be. This is something I can find out through people that I work with or have similar interests with, also, through research on our Web 2.0. With affiliation and cooperation, they have given me a challenge. I am now in the notion of working with the ideas involved in both, such as; affiliating with the use of the Social affiliation model, of which I have mentioned in my task 3B as being believable with the exception of emotions. But, giving this much thought, I think at times we must be able to keep our emotions under control, therefore I will be concentrating on seeing if the social affiliation model can work for me within the workplace and at home when affiliating online or via my phone. With cooperation, I have been very aware of my cooperating skills within my networks. It assists my thinking in a Reflection IN action way. Same goes for the Social affiliation model. I consider these concepts will benefit me somehow, particularly in being more organized and thinking in action within my networks. I believe that they will helpme to grow as a professional.
Are you left thinking differently prior to this part of the module? Everything that I have written above is mostly different to how my mind worked prior to Part 3. There isn't much to say, as I've written it all above. All I can say is that I am definitely thinking in a more professional manner and that I feel more proficient in my knowledge of such things within psychology and why we do things, certain aspects of teamwork and what teamwork actually means, and what profits they have and how I can actually help myself rather than letting people help me. I've also realized what subjects glue me to the screen or paper, and how I can use this in a very beneficial way.
Something that I'd like to add is something Laura-May Houghton wrote in her task 3B [see link at the top]. She said; "how long will it take before we start paying monthly for these valuable resources?" I have commented twice on this blog but for some reason they keep disappearing, so I will write here what I had written;
Hi Laura
This has been a great read.
The thing that stood out was the question about how long before we start paying for our resources.
It truly is a scary thought. It made me think about how useless I am at using these valuable resources, and how I really don't give them enough thought. I would regret it if they start adding charges. Even though it shouldn't be a reason to neglect these resources, but it shows how much I and many others take these resources for granted. There are a few job sites that I am signed up on but hardly ever look through them, I would be kicking myself if they start charging monthly payments.
It's a great realization and it's something for us all to think about.
Thanks for that.
Kim x
This has definitely left me thinking differently prior to this part of the module. I am guilty for taking stuff for granted, and I'm sure I'm not the only one.
So, use and abuse while you still can.
Good luck to everyone on their Critical Reflection Essay!!
'Keeeeeep blogging'
Tuesday, 24 December 2013
Monday, 16 December 2013
Task 3C Sources of information
http://melaniebrown10.blogspot.co.uk/2012/11/3c-5-most-important-sources-of.html
http://annatimms.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/task-3c-my-5-most-important-sources-of.html
I've decided on my approach to this task by the influence of the two blogs above; Melanie Brown and Anna Timms. They have both put their sources of information into a list of top sources of information.
1. SHAZAM via the internet.
http://teachingcarla.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/my-sources-of-information.html
In Carla Mason's blog [see link] she mentions about the ever changing styles of music and how she has to keep up with the times, especially being a teacher (like myself). The Internet is so very important for this as, like I've mentioned before, unlike Carla's method on just remembering the words and googling them up later, I use the fantastic Shazam application on my smartphone to grasp a song that I've heard in a shop or at work, of which I can then use for my teaching and choreography. I can know the name of the song right there and then.
It's become a very important source of information for me, and naturally my smartphone and the internet are equally as important, as without them, I can't use Shazam. I do think that it's vital to find out different methods to make your life easier in any profession. I only found out about Shazam when I heard a song that I've heard before come on in a shop and I was absolutely kicking myself because nobody I was with knew what it was. Fortunately, one of them knew about Shazam, and TA DAA! Meeting with people has been mentioned in the Module 1 Handbook as a good source of technology to use to get information, and the information I have received from doing this is another source of information. It just proves that if you make that effort to affiliate with others, which in turn can be an information-network, other sources of information can emerge.
2. TEACHERS/EMPLOYERS
I haven't been long in the teaching profession, therefore, I have a lot to learn about the profession. Fellow teachers who are more experienced and well qualified are extremely useful sources of information for me. They are like my support. I am wanting to boost my qualifications to be able to teach in more established environments with a more secure wage, hence I value any information that I receive from them, relating to qualifications that will suit my desired career path. They are also useful in getting a variety of different methods to use in teaching that may be worth my trying, to improve my teaching skills.
I think the more teachers I get to know the more profound the knowledge will be. You can't just trust in one teacher as they may have errors in their knowledge, even if they've been teaching for many years. It is like the Web 2.0 which we've worked on in the beginning. The more research you do, the more specific the outcome will be. I think to help make truth of what other teachers have said, it's best to do a bit of research via the internet for confirmation. Employers and fellow teachers are in my top sources of information also because they keep me in the know and may know of new job opportunities which is always a bonus.
3. FAMILY/FRIENDS/FRIENDS OF FAMILY AND FRIENDS
I am extremely fortunate to have a family of teachers. Like I've mentioned before, my mum, dad, brother sister, auntie, uncle and nan are/were all teachers. It's not even that it's been pushed upon me to do it, it's just something I've always wanted to do ever since I was about ten years old. Runs in the blood. We are all also musical with the exception of my nan. They are my most reliable source of information as we are all very close and will benefit from any information on teaching skills. I must admit that I very rarely ask for their help and advice. Being related, our qualities in teaching are similar and with that in mind, I can feed off their ideas greatly. They each have their strong points. My sister is very organized and knows a lot of useful job websites which is, naturally, very vital. My brother knows his musical tools (Cubase of which I've mentioned before). He was the one who gave me that forever handy information. My mum teaches a variety of age groups, therefore, she is full of convenient knowledge on how she deals with each age group and how she portrays herself. I don't copy every single approach that she advises, but I work with them to suit my ways.
There are of course friends and friends of family and friends. Most of the people my family socializes with have similar interests, or are teachers, and some of my friends are looking into the same profession as me and friends of theirs. Like with my fellow teachers, these people are all great for keeping me in the know, having news of possible job positions and wonderful for support. Giving each other ideas and being sympathetic makes friends a more personal supportive network. They keep me sane.
4. NEWSPAPER/JOB SITES
So, again the internet plays a vital role when it comes to job sites and new information. Indeed.com and TES are great sites with some wonderful dance teaching opportunities. As you can see the internet plays such an important role in most of my information sources, and for most individuals. It is one of my main sources of information. Newspapers also keep me in the know and advertises many teaching jobs. I used to get The Stage for performance opportunities. I always found that it had more adverts that The Stage website, which shows that the internet isn't always the most useful source, but in most cases it's very important.
5. BAPP BLOGS
Blogging has of course been a new and very useful source of information. I have found out about different ways that others communicate, different views and ideas, how they deal with certain things, what things they benefit from etc. But, blogging has been the source of information that helps me adapt my own thinking and ideas. Going through other students' blogs, who are further into the course, is interesting as they communicate in a different way with their fellow students and some of their layouts and ideas are much different. It's given more variety towards my thinking and has given me even more beneficial information.
Conclusion
I honestly wouldn't know what I'd do without my phone, laptop and internet. How did they cope a hundred years ago? Well I guess the answer is; that they would have had to walk or cycle down to the shop to buy the latest newspapers with job opportunities and they would send letters to friends and family via the post to keep in the know when they live so far. They would have to remember the lyrics to the songs to try to find out what it is and who it's by and go to their local record store for information. We still have these options today, but technology has come so far that we don't have to do all of that walking, cycling, posting and noting down.
Meeting with family and friends hasn't changed much. We still find it the most beneficial when we meet up rather than talking over the phone or on the internet. It's a shame how facebook, twitter or texting can take over peoples' lives and they become lazy and don't make the effort to go out and actually physically be amongst their friends and family. Talking of affiliation in the previous task, if there is a lack of close affiliation, you can become lonely or are less able to cope with stress. (Gunnar, 2000) But in the subject of sources of information, I believe that communicating by phone, internet or in person are all just as constructive, depending on the subject
Other source of information.
Carla Mason, [see link in Shazam] spoke about Television being a useful source of information for her.
I think this is a great source, and I don't know why I don't use this to my advantage enough. I don't watch as much television as whence I used to, which is a very reasonable explanation. She said; 'Films have a lot of great soundtracks'. I agree entirely. I know of the film 'August Rush' having a great soundtrack, also I remember a 1992 movie called 'Wuthering heights' which also has a great theme tune. Very emotional.: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Srg_R-NoXGg Listen from 1:10.
I disagree that the television only plays popular music. I don't believe this is true at all. There are so many adverts that play music that I've never heard and of course soundtracks in movies that have been composed specifically for that particular movie.
Television will be used as a source of information (music or the news) for me in future. I will start making the effort to doing this as I know it will serve me very well.
'Keeeep blogging'
x
http://annatimms.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/task-3c-my-5-most-important-sources-of.html
I've decided on my approach to this task by the influence of the two blogs above; Melanie Brown and Anna Timms. They have both put their sources of information into a list of top sources of information.
1. SHAZAM via the internet.
http://teachingcarla.blogspot.co.uk/2013/04/my-sources-of-information.html
In Carla Mason's blog [see link] she mentions about the ever changing styles of music and how she has to keep up with the times, especially being a teacher (like myself). The Internet is so very important for this as, like I've mentioned before, unlike Carla's method on just remembering the words and googling them up later, I use the fantastic Shazam application on my smartphone to grasp a song that I've heard in a shop or at work, of which I can then use for my teaching and choreography. I can know the name of the song right there and then.
It's become a very important source of information for me, and naturally my smartphone and the internet are equally as important, as without them, I can't use Shazam. I do think that it's vital to find out different methods to make your life easier in any profession. I only found out about Shazam when I heard a song that I've heard before come on in a shop and I was absolutely kicking myself because nobody I was with knew what it was. Fortunately, one of them knew about Shazam, and TA DAA! Meeting with people has been mentioned in the Module 1 Handbook as a good source of technology to use to get information, and the information I have received from doing this is another source of information. It just proves that if you make that effort to affiliate with others, which in turn can be an information-network, other sources of information can emerge.
2. TEACHERS/EMPLOYERS
I haven't been long in the teaching profession, therefore, I have a lot to learn about the profession. Fellow teachers who are more experienced and well qualified are extremely useful sources of information for me. They are like my support. I am wanting to boost my qualifications to be able to teach in more established environments with a more secure wage, hence I value any information that I receive from them, relating to qualifications that will suit my desired career path. They are also useful in getting a variety of different methods to use in teaching that may be worth my trying, to improve my teaching skills.
I think the more teachers I get to know the more profound the knowledge will be. You can't just trust in one teacher as they may have errors in their knowledge, even if they've been teaching for many years. It is like the Web 2.0 which we've worked on in the beginning. The more research you do, the more specific the outcome will be. I think to help make truth of what other teachers have said, it's best to do a bit of research via the internet for confirmation. Employers and fellow teachers are in my top sources of information also because they keep me in the know and may know of new job opportunities which is always a bonus.
3. FAMILY/FRIENDS/FRIENDS OF FAMILY AND FRIENDS
I am extremely fortunate to have a family of teachers. Like I've mentioned before, my mum, dad, brother sister, auntie, uncle and nan are/were all teachers. It's not even that it's been pushed upon me to do it, it's just something I've always wanted to do ever since I was about ten years old. Runs in the blood. We are all also musical with the exception of my nan. They are my most reliable source of information as we are all very close and will benefit from any information on teaching skills. I must admit that I very rarely ask for their help and advice. Being related, our qualities in teaching are similar and with that in mind, I can feed off their ideas greatly. They each have their strong points. My sister is very organized and knows a lot of useful job websites which is, naturally, very vital. My brother knows his musical tools (Cubase of which I've mentioned before). He was the one who gave me that forever handy information. My mum teaches a variety of age groups, therefore, she is full of convenient knowledge on how she deals with each age group and how she portrays herself. I don't copy every single approach that she advises, but I work with them to suit my ways.
There are of course friends and friends of family and friends. Most of the people my family socializes with have similar interests, or are teachers, and some of my friends are looking into the same profession as me and friends of theirs. Like with my fellow teachers, these people are all great for keeping me in the know, having news of possible job positions and wonderful for support. Giving each other ideas and being sympathetic makes friends a more personal supportive network. They keep me sane.
4. NEWSPAPER/JOB SITES
So, again the internet plays a vital role when it comes to job sites and new information. Indeed.com and TES are great sites with some wonderful dance teaching opportunities. As you can see the internet plays such an important role in most of my information sources, and for most individuals. It is one of my main sources of information. Newspapers also keep me in the know and advertises many teaching jobs. I used to get The Stage for performance opportunities. I always found that it had more adverts that The Stage website, which shows that the internet isn't always the most useful source, but in most cases it's very important.
5. BAPP BLOGS
Blogging has of course been a new and very useful source of information. I have found out about different ways that others communicate, different views and ideas, how they deal with certain things, what things they benefit from etc. But, blogging has been the source of information that helps me adapt my own thinking and ideas. Going through other students' blogs, who are further into the course, is interesting as they communicate in a different way with their fellow students and some of their layouts and ideas are much different. It's given more variety towards my thinking and has given me even more beneficial information.
Conclusion
I honestly wouldn't know what I'd do without my phone, laptop and internet. How did they cope a hundred years ago? Well I guess the answer is; that they would have had to walk or cycle down to the shop to buy the latest newspapers with job opportunities and they would send letters to friends and family via the post to keep in the know when they live so far. They would have to remember the lyrics to the songs to try to find out what it is and who it's by and go to their local record store for information. We still have these options today, but technology has come so far that we don't have to do all of that walking, cycling, posting and noting down.
Meeting with family and friends hasn't changed much. We still find it the most beneficial when we meet up rather than talking over the phone or on the internet. It's a shame how facebook, twitter or texting can take over peoples' lives and they become lazy and don't make the effort to go out and actually physically be amongst their friends and family. Talking of affiliation in the previous task, if there is a lack of close affiliation, you can become lonely or are less able to cope with stress. (Gunnar, 2000) But in the subject of sources of information, I believe that communicating by phone, internet or in person are all just as constructive, depending on the subject
Other source of information.
Carla Mason, [see link in Shazam] spoke about Television being a useful source of information for her.
I think this is a great source, and I don't know why I don't use this to my advantage enough. I don't watch as much television as whence I used to, which is a very reasonable explanation. She said; 'Films have a lot of great soundtracks'. I agree entirely. I know of the film 'August Rush' having a great soundtrack, also I remember a 1992 movie called 'Wuthering heights' which also has a great theme tune. Very emotional.: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Srg_R-NoXGg Listen from 1:10.
I disagree that the television only plays popular music. I don't believe this is true at all. There are so many adverts that play music that I've never heard and of course soundtracks in movies that have been composed specifically for that particular movie.
Television will be used as a source of information (music or the news) for me in future. I will start making the effort to doing this as I know it will serve me very well.
'Keeeep blogging'
x
Tuesday, 10 December 2013
Task 3B Theories relating to networking
For me this task was based on Cooperation and Affiliation. They were the only sections that were highlighted as 'concepts'.
COOPERATION
The Prisoners' Dilemma.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/playground/pd.html
As given in Reader 3, I took on the 'perplexing game' of the Prisoner's dilemma.(see link) Robert Axelrod; a political scientist, talks about 'Tit for Tat' which means a "..strategy of starting with cooperation, and thereafter doing what the other player did on the previous move". (Axelrod, The evolution of cooperation, page 8[viii]) This was the strategy used by the Serendip in the game. Here were the strategies I used:
It would seem, that cooperation is the best strategy when working in a team or where nobody has to end up on top. This will gain for one another the best results, individually or as a whole. In a selfish way, cooperating until the last move or two seems to be the best strategy. So I agree with Axelrod on; "..the importance of the notion of cooperation, and in particular, the benefits of cooperating fully with others, until you reach a point of maximum benefit, and then to 'defect'." (Axelrod, Reader 3, p5) But only when it means that you want to come out on top.
Axelrod explains how using the Tit for Tat method was the strategy used that came out on top in his experiment. In the Prisoners Dilemma game that I did, it rings true that it is the strongest method to 'keep up' so to speak, but not as the best method (with the exception of the opposition cooperating the whole time), especially when getting the maximum benefit, for example; the Serendip was always using Tit for Tat, but never actually came out on top. The Serendip was either equal to me or beneath me in the end results. But as I've said the Tit for Tat method does show that you are not so far apart in results by keeping up, but always being second best. In reality, if the opposition using the Tit for Tat method accidently makes one false move, the opposition can take advantage.
It's really hard to truly understand without trying it out in reality, but I will stick to my guns on cooperating fully with others til the end, or cooperating fully until the last minute. Cooperating continually does have that Tit for Tat strategy in there, as both are, of course, Tit for Tat-'ing' one another.
Below is a wonderful way to express the advantage of cooperation:
'..it is easy to imagine that two wolves together would be able to kill an animal that is more than twice as large as the largest one each of them might have killed on his own. Even if an altruistic wolf would kill a rabbit and give it to another wolf, and the other wolf would do nothing in return, the selfish wolf would still have less to eat than if he had helped his companion to kill a deer. Yet we will assume that the synergistic effect is smaller than the gains made by defection (i.e. letting someone help you without doing anything in return).' (http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/PRISDIL.html)
It is true that some people are deceived by competition, I think until now, I was a little bit deceived too.
I've always preferred team work, and I'm glad it proves to be a better and more advantageous way for everyone, even if somebody decides to defect last minute, the others will still have achieved more than if they had competed the entire time.
This has truly been an eye opener. I can use this for my teaching skills. My fellow colleague and I can discuss which ways can be a better approach in the lessons, of which can help both of us improve on our teaching skills and build up our qualities. This can also help to achieve a better result of our students' performances and give them a better chance of learning and give them a more favorable experience. I for one want to be noticed for my creativity, consequently receiving other possible opportunities. I can also try and find out what the other teachers do to produce great results, and adapt them into my work somehow. (Tit for Tat)
With my choreography, using the strategy of cooperating til the last minute can serve to be beneficial in any situation where I am indirectly competing against some more established choreographers, with the same or similar approach as me.
In Megan Lewis' blog, she made me think about how relationships can break down by cooperating until the last move. It truly is something to contemplate as you must keep relationships steady, else you won't actually have a close working network to work with. You will have put peoples' backs up. http://napatnoon.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/task-3b.html She mentions how she believes cooperation leads to a more harmonious life. There is a lot to consider when deciding the right pursuit. I agree with Megan on this. Cooperation described as the 'will and way to win' by Alan Durrant in Reader 3, I now absolutely buy into, thoroughly, on a professional and personal understanding.
AFFILIATION
When and why we affiliate.
From my own understanding, we affiliate due to natural human instinct and intelligence; "our tendency to seek out others and form close relationships is an inherited trait that that helps us to survive and reproduce by providing us with a network of support that will help us when we are in need." (Crisp and Turner, Essential social psychology, p323) I've also come to the understanding that everybody has different levels of social stimulation; 'Introvert and Extrovert' (Reader 3, p6) which means some people who are introvert are more inclined to stay clear of much social interactions and extroverts are inclined to socialize more to keep to their each desired level of social stimulation.
Talking of desires to affiliate, I have been debating which explanation of determinants of affiliation makes more sense, to me. The Privacy regulation theory brought about by Irwin Altman, (Crisp and Turner, Essential social psychology, p323) which was inspired by the 'dialectic principle' and 'optimization principle,' brings forth that the desire for privacy and affiliation can alternate in the space of a few hours and you can try to even out your desired levels with your actual levels of privacy and affiliation. For me, I think the Privacy regulation theory is more related to how I see myself and how I deal with my desires of affiliation. With the Social affiliation model (O'Connor and Rosenblood, '96) it provides the idea that we can regulate our desired level of affiliation on a daily basis. Like a routine. (homeostasis) I do find this true, but only with the exception of emotions as I think they haven't been taken into account. I really believe that emotions can disorder the routine. This goes especially for females. I believe that emotions can get in the way of a mental routine and particularly affiliation. So I do lean more towards the Privacy regulation theory more. I think that when I was at school, I definitely had a regular pattern and I could easily control my needs to affiliate. But, whenever I had to affiliate at my normal privacy time, for example; sports day or after school rehearsals, it would throw me off guard. With this, I definitely took on the optimization principle by evening out my desired levels to affiliate and not. I'm sure that there are a lot of people who would actually struggle with this principle, but would still try.
This is quite an fascinating encounter as I'm quite interested in psychology.
When thinking about individual differences in affiliation, (in relation to biological explanations), extroverts and introverts; as mentioned above, has been quite intriguing. (Crisp and Turner, Essential social psychology, p324) I think that I am a bit of both of these. Some days I am very much extrovert and try engaging more with my friends, family and work colleagues to gain some stimulation. Yet other days, I just want to be by myself as I gain enough stimulation with my own mind. But, saying this, I do find myself to be a bit more extrovert, but I don't put enough effort into affiliating with others. I think that I would feel more content if I were to do so. I do live with my other half, and I feel that with that in mind, I am actually more than content. I know that I keep contradicting myself, and it now makes me think that I perhaps don't need to go out to affiliate with others. Maybe this is the reason why I don't? Not because I haven't put in any effort, but because I have affiliation constantly within my own living space on a highly emotional level.
Talking about cultural affiliation differences, (which has also been intriguing), connects greatly to my other half's culture. He is from a country which has a collectivist culture. I researched more into Individualistic and Collectivist countries, and this link proves to be the best for me to gain a true understanding: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/orudenstam/2012/10/05/individualism-vs-collectivism/
My other half is very close to his family and me, and isn't one for socializing at all. I on the other hand, being from an Individualistic culture (Great Britain), do feel the need for some socialization. I am too very close to my family and definitely put them first when it comes to choosing a night out with my best friend or a movie night with my sister. With this in mind, I still have the need to see my best friend and affiliate at another time. My partner doesn't have any close friends, and only seems to socialize, in a very distant manner, at his work place.
On a more personal level, this subject has been most appealing as it proves to be very true because of my current situation. I have definitely changed over the years to how much I feel the need to affiliate with others. When I was in my teens I would find satisfaction in just being around people, even if they weren't so close to me. Now I haven't got the need to affiliate so much. I seem to have adjusted to being in between individualism and collectivism, and I'm definitely more extrovert on a more personal level but introvert on a not so personal level.
With that in mind, on a professional level, being that bit more extrovert deliberately, would prove to be very useful in any career. I understand now that being slightly introvert isn't right or wrong, but using the Optimization principle can turn out to be very valuable within the workplace. There is always an individual being the 'life of the party' in any job, but it doesn't have to be you or me. As long as you keep a stable relationship with that person and everyone, good things can come out of it such as great opportunities and being able to cooperate without a sour atmosphere.
When I was at college, the phrase; 'seeking affiliation can be fraught by discomfort and anxiety' rings very true to that time in my life and a few other people that I know. (Crisp and Turner, Essential differences in affiliation, p324) There were a lot of people who had already begun friendship ties. Myself and a few others had to make an effort to seek affiliation. Being quite careful about who I socialized with and not having the confidence to bring up conversations (especially in an almost daunting environment), this was incredibly hard, hence, discomfort and anxiety came about quite highly. This was a real learning curve for me, and now this subject on affiliation has made me look at myself. I realize that being careful gives a negative impact and I think people thought that I thought myself as high and mighty, which was the complete opposite.
Learning from these times has been very convenient and now I am a lot more open with people in the workplace. To begin with I was very much out of my comfort zone, but now it's become natural and doesn't cause any uneasiness. I think being yourself is extremely important when affiliating with others, even in the beginning stage.
All of the aspects above on affiliation has been incredibly inspiring and I will be applying them into my current and future positions in teaching. Fortunately there is a new music teacher starting next term and I will make the effort to use some of the concepts mentioned above by being myself, leveling out my desires to affiliate and make my extrovert manner more conscious and use it to my best ability. I can give her my email address and phone number whenever she has questions or just wants to build a good working relationship.
We all need good working relationships.
'Keeeep Blogging'
COOPERATION
The Prisoners' Dilemma.
http://serendip.brynmawr.edu/playground/pd.html
As given in Reader 3, I took on the 'perplexing game' of the Prisoner's dilemma.(see link) Robert Axelrod; a political scientist, talks about 'Tit for Tat' which means a "..strategy of starting with cooperation, and thereafter doing what the other player did on the previous move". (Axelrod, The evolution of cooperation, page 8[viii]) This was the strategy used by the Serendip in the game. Here were the strategies I used:
- Continually cooperating the entire time.
- Continually competing the entire time.
- Cooperating until the last move or few moves.
- Competing until the last move or few moves.
- Alternating cooperation and competition on every move.
It would seem, that cooperation is the best strategy when working in a team or where nobody has to end up on top. This will gain for one another the best results, individually or as a whole. In a selfish way, cooperating until the last move or two seems to be the best strategy. So I agree with Axelrod on; "..the importance of the notion of cooperation, and in particular, the benefits of cooperating fully with others, until you reach a point of maximum benefit, and then to 'defect'." (Axelrod, Reader 3, p5) But only when it means that you want to come out on top.
Axelrod explains how using the Tit for Tat method was the strategy used that came out on top in his experiment. In the Prisoners Dilemma game that I did, it rings true that it is the strongest method to 'keep up' so to speak, but not as the best method (with the exception of the opposition cooperating the whole time), especially when getting the maximum benefit, for example; the Serendip was always using Tit for Tat, but never actually came out on top. The Serendip was either equal to me or beneath me in the end results. But as I've said the Tit for Tat method does show that you are not so far apart in results by keeping up, but always being second best. In reality, if the opposition using the Tit for Tat method accidently makes one false move, the opposition can take advantage.
It's really hard to truly understand without trying it out in reality, but I will stick to my guns on cooperating fully with others til the end, or cooperating fully until the last minute. Cooperating continually does have that Tit for Tat strategy in there, as both are, of course, Tit for Tat-'ing' one another.
Below is a wonderful way to express the advantage of cooperation:
'..it is easy to imagine that two wolves together would be able to kill an animal that is more than twice as large as the largest one each of them might have killed on his own. Even if an altruistic wolf would kill a rabbit and give it to another wolf, and the other wolf would do nothing in return, the selfish wolf would still have less to eat than if he had helped his companion to kill a deer. Yet we will assume that the synergistic effect is smaller than the gains made by defection (i.e. letting someone help you without doing anything in return).' (http://pespmc1.vub.ac.be/PRISDIL.html)
It is true that some people are deceived by competition, I think until now, I was a little bit deceived too.
I've always preferred team work, and I'm glad it proves to be a better and more advantageous way for everyone, even if somebody decides to defect last minute, the others will still have achieved more than if they had competed the entire time.
This has truly been an eye opener. I can use this for my teaching skills. My fellow colleague and I can discuss which ways can be a better approach in the lessons, of which can help both of us improve on our teaching skills and build up our qualities. This can also help to achieve a better result of our students' performances and give them a better chance of learning and give them a more favorable experience. I for one want to be noticed for my creativity, consequently receiving other possible opportunities. I can also try and find out what the other teachers do to produce great results, and adapt them into my work somehow. (Tit for Tat)
With my choreography, using the strategy of cooperating til the last minute can serve to be beneficial in any situation where I am indirectly competing against some more established choreographers, with the same or similar approach as me.
In Megan Lewis' blog, she made me think about how relationships can break down by cooperating until the last move. It truly is something to contemplate as you must keep relationships steady, else you won't actually have a close working network to work with. You will have put peoples' backs up. http://napatnoon.blogspot.co.uk/2013/11/task-3b.html She mentions how she believes cooperation leads to a more harmonious life. There is a lot to consider when deciding the right pursuit. I agree with Megan on this. Cooperation described as the 'will and way to win' by Alan Durrant in Reader 3, I now absolutely buy into, thoroughly, on a professional and personal understanding.
AFFILIATION
When and why we affiliate.
From my own understanding, we affiliate due to natural human instinct and intelligence; "our tendency to seek out others and form close relationships is an inherited trait that that helps us to survive and reproduce by providing us with a network of support that will help us when we are in need." (Crisp and Turner, Essential social psychology, p323) I've also come to the understanding that everybody has different levels of social stimulation; 'Introvert and Extrovert' (Reader 3, p6) which means some people who are introvert are more inclined to stay clear of much social interactions and extroverts are inclined to socialize more to keep to their each desired level of social stimulation.
Talking of desires to affiliate, I have been debating which explanation of determinants of affiliation makes more sense, to me. The Privacy regulation theory brought about by Irwin Altman, (Crisp and Turner, Essential social psychology, p323) which was inspired by the 'dialectic principle' and 'optimization principle,' brings forth that the desire for privacy and affiliation can alternate in the space of a few hours and you can try to even out your desired levels with your actual levels of privacy and affiliation. For me, I think the Privacy regulation theory is more related to how I see myself and how I deal with my desires of affiliation. With the Social affiliation model (O'Connor and Rosenblood, '96) it provides the idea that we can regulate our desired level of affiliation on a daily basis. Like a routine. (homeostasis) I do find this true, but only with the exception of emotions as I think they haven't been taken into account. I really believe that emotions can disorder the routine. This goes especially for females. I believe that emotions can get in the way of a mental routine and particularly affiliation. So I do lean more towards the Privacy regulation theory more. I think that when I was at school, I definitely had a regular pattern and I could easily control my needs to affiliate. But, whenever I had to affiliate at my normal privacy time, for example; sports day or after school rehearsals, it would throw me off guard. With this, I definitely took on the optimization principle by evening out my desired levels to affiliate and not. I'm sure that there are a lot of people who would actually struggle with this principle, but would still try.
This is quite an fascinating encounter as I'm quite interested in psychology.
When thinking about individual differences in affiliation, (in relation to biological explanations), extroverts and introverts; as mentioned above, has been quite intriguing. (Crisp and Turner, Essential social psychology, p324) I think that I am a bit of both of these. Some days I am very much extrovert and try engaging more with my friends, family and work colleagues to gain some stimulation. Yet other days, I just want to be by myself as I gain enough stimulation with my own mind. But, saying this, I do find myself to be a bit more extrovert, but I don't put enough effort into affiliating with others. I think that I would feel more content if I were to do so. I do live with my other half, and I feel that with that in mind, I am actually more than content. I know that I keep contradicting myself, and it now makes me think that I perhaps don't need to go out to affiliate with others. Maybe this is the reason why I don't? Not because I haven't put in any effort, but because I have affiliation constantly within my own living space on a highly emotional level.
Talking about cultural affiliation differences, (which has also been intriguing), connects greatly to my other half's culture. He is from a country which has a collectivist culture. I researched more into Individualistic and Collectivist countries, and this link proves to be the best for me to gain a true understanding: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/orudenstam/2012/10/05/individualism-vs-collectivism/
My other half is very close to his family and me, and isn't one for socializing at all. I on the other hand, being from an Individualistic culture (Great Britain), do feel the need for some socialization. I am too very close to my family and definitely put them first when it comes to choosing a night out with my best friend or a movie night with my sister. With this in mind, I still have the need to see my best friend and affiliate at another time. My partner doesn't have any close friends, and only seems to socialize, in a very distant manner, at his work place.
On a more personal level, this subject has been most appealing as it proves to be very true because of my current situation. I have definitely changed over the years to how much I feel the need to affiliate with others. When I was in my teens I would find satisfaction in just being around people, even if they weren't so close to me. Now I haven't got the need to affiliate so much. I seem to have adjusted to being in between individualism and collectivism, and I'm definitely more extrovert on a more personal level but introvert on a not so personal level.
With that in mind, on a professional level, being that bit more extrovert deliberately, would prove to be very useful in any career. I understand now that being slightly introvert isn't right or wrong, but using the Optimization principle can turn out to be very valuable within the workplace. There is always an individual being the 'life of the party' in any job, but it doesn't have to be you or me. As long as you keep a stable relationship with that person and everyone, good things can come out of it such as great opportunities and being able to cooperate without a sour atmosphere.
When I was at college, the phrase; 'seeking affiliation can be fraught by discomfort and anxiety' rings very true to that time in my life and a few other people that I know. (Crisp and Turner, Essential differences in affiliation, p324) There were a lot of people who had already begun friendship ties. Myself and a few others had to make an effort to seek affiliation. Being quite careful about who I socialized with and not having the confidence to bring up conversations (especially in an almost daunting environment), this was incredibly hard, hence, discomfort and anxiety came about quite highly. This was a real learning curve for me, and now this subject on affiliation has made me look at myself. I realize that being careful gives a negative impact and I think people thought that I thought myself as high and mighty, which was the complete opposite.
Learning from these times has been very convenient and now I am a lot more open with people in the workplace. To begin with I was very much out of my comfort zone, but now it's become natural and doesn't cause any uneasiness. I think being yourself is extremely important when affiliating with others, even in the beginning stage.
All of the aspects above on affiliation has been incredibly inspiring and I will be applying them into my current and future positions in teaching. Fortunately there is a new music teacher starting next term and I will make the effort to use some of the concepts mentioned above by being myself, leveling out my desires to affiliate and make my extrovert manner more conscious and use it to my best ability. I can give her my email address and phone number whenever she has questions or just wants to build a good working relationship.
We all need good working relationships.
'Keeeep Blogging'
Wednesday, 4 December 2013
Task 3A Current Networks
This is the subject in which I initially thought; "Networks!! Arghhh I don't think I have a lot of those" when actually looking up on the different articles from the reading lists and the Reader itself, I began to realise: "Oh, so networks aren't just associated with technology". (I'm sure I wasn't the only one who thought this..) If I was, well, what a 'numpty'.
Probably my most valuable people within my professional network are my family. Both my Mum and Dad and my two siblings are teachers and have a real passion for performing in some way. There is always face-to-face communication, emailing, texting and talking over the phone with my family when it comes to talking about work and even speaking of it, somehow, indirectly.
I do find that I am very weak at my networking abilities and skills, especially when it comes to the people I know who have more distant, but related interests. This is something I need to work on and understand better for me to benefit from my network communities. I know how important various different skills are of which I've gotten from Siemens 2004 extract. (George Siemens, WBS3730 in Bapp arts, reading lists).
My other half is a manager in retail, and he has many different ways to use his networks. Firstly he speaks to other managers one to one, about how they cope in certain situations and how they've been hitting targets etc. He gains quite a bit of knowledge by doing this and tries it out for himself, almost like a Tit for Tat method, which is mentioned by Axelrod in The Prisoners' Dilemma. (Robert Axelrod, WBS3730 in Bapp arts, reading lists) There is a lot of competition in his work, so it really is like a game. He also has many meetings which he uses to gain understanding on products and it's uses, and therefore debating what he can actually do with this knowledge to better himself and to be top of the region. In the meetings, his superiors will talk about what standards they expect and what approaches they want them to use, and give information on good practice that they have seen from other managers. He speaks with his manager one on one via email and phone quite often to find out more information that can benefit his work, and asks for advice.
The customers also play a big role in his networking as they give feedback about their service that they received etc, hence he learns from anything positive and builds on it, and learns anything negative and corrects it. He keeps in contact with a few of his past colleagues, and use them to get information on other potential job positions going, of which are better paid or closer to home.
I often speak with my best friend on beauty products and routines. What hair products we use, or what hair dye we use, and make up etc. We always practice with something that the other has used to see for ourselves whether it's right thing to use for us individually. My best friend also works with children but of a very young age, and she has been doing this for many years now. So there is some use of my best friend in a professional manner, as I can learn from her experiences with children. Trial and error, the same as with the beauty products.
When I'm with a bunch of people, I tend to be quite inquisitive about how their lives are going, for example; their love life. I find out all sorts of information on their relationships and how they deal with certain situations and arguments. Some of it is rather typical, but sometimes it's rather unique and it makes me think about my own relationship and how I deal with situations. Sometimes I gather up some of their unintentional advice, and see how it works within my relationship. This is advice on my own reactions to things within the relationships and to perhaps stop and think before I do or say anything. I can use this method in asking about how their working life is going, and seeing where it leads.
I also work side a girl who as not long graduated from stage school. She just wants a job, either teaching or performing. Naturally she always asks me questions and asks for advice, particularly on the performing side. I give her contacts and websites to visit that can give her more of a chance of getting auditions and interviews.
Generally, people are in it for themselves in a professional network, but are also there as a guide to others.
In social networking, it's about sharing experiences and asking advice in more usual everyday things. Affiliation is more for the social in most people's lives. I believe that people who are more introvert benefit from the technology form of networking a lot more than extroverts, purely because extroverts want to get out there and be noticed and want to learn this way.
I can also ask around for advice from people who may have done a similar thing or plan to. Maybe I can team up with somebody to create the ideal network.
I need to use my inquisitiveness in my professional networks and ask into peoples careers and people they may know.
There is definitely more that I don't know in my current and intended networks. For example, I don't know how many potential connections are out there for me. I don't believe I have many connections, but it's probably all hidden from me, just because I haven't gotten myself out there to try and find them.
I want to teach. I know that there must be some connections to other teachers or people associated with schools or dance schools.
'Keeeeep Blogging'
- What are the current and different ways (tools) that you have, or do, engage your professional network?
Probably my most valuable people within my professional network are my family. Both my Mum and Dad and my two siblings are teachers and have a real passion for performing in some way. There is always face-to-face communication, emailing, texting and talking over the phone with my family when it comes to talking about work and even speaking of it, somehow, indirectly.
I do find that I am very weak at my networking abilities and skills, especially when it comes to the people I know who have more distant, but related interests. This is something I need to work on and understand better for me to benefit from my network communities. I know how important various different skills are of which I've gotten from Siemens 2004 extract. (George Siemens, WBS3730 in Bapp arts, reading lists).
- What are the established (and different) ways that others use their networks, especially if they are more established or experienced practitioners that you admire?
My other half is a manager in retail, and he has many different ways to use his networks. Firstly he speaks to other managers one to one, about how they cope in certain situations and how they've been hitting targets etc. He gains quite a bit of knowledge by doing this and tries it out for himself, almost like a Tit for Tat method, which is mentioned by Axelrod in The Prisoners' Dilemma. (Robert Axelrod, WBS3730 in Bapp arts, reading lists) There is a lot of competition in his work, so it really is like a game. He also has many meetings which he uses to gain understanding on products and it's uses, and therefore debating what he can actually do with this knowledge to better himself and to be top of the region. In the meetings, his superiors will talk about what standards they expect and what approaches they want them to use, and give information on good practice that they have seen from other managers. He speaks with his manager one on one via email and phone quite often to find out more information that can benefit his work, and asks for advice.
The customers also play a big role in his networking as they give feedback about their service that they received etc, hence he learns from anything positive and builds on it, and learns anything negative and corrects it. He keeps in contact with a few of his past colleagues, and use them to get information on other potential job positions going, of which are better paid or closer to home.
- Are there methods, approaches and technologies that you use socially that might apply and help you develop your professional networking?
I often speak with my best friend on beauty products and routines. What hair products we use, or what hair dye we use, and make up etc. We always practice with something that the other has used to see for ourselves whether it's right thing to use for us individually. My best friend also works with children but of a very young age, and she has been doing this for many years now. So there is some use of my best friend in a professional manner, as I can learn from her experiences with children. Trial and error, the same as with the beauty products.
When I'm with a bunch of people, I tend to be quite inquisitive about how their lives are going, for example; their love life. I find out all sorts of information on their relationships and how they deal with certain situations and arguments. Some of it is rather typical, but sometimes it's rather unique and it makes me think about my own relationship and how I deal with situations. Sometimes I gather up some of their unintentional advice, and see how it works within my relationship. This is advice on my own reactions to things within the relationships and to perhaps stop and think before I do or say anything. I can use this method in asking about how their working life is going, and seeing where it leads.
- When you reflect upon current networks, can you think about the motives of others to be in the network and what values and purpose they have in mind?
I also work side a girl who as not long graduated from stage school. She just wants a job, either teaching or performing. Naturally she always asks me questions and asks for advice, particularly on the performing side. I give her contacts and websites to visit that can give her more of a chance of getting auditions and interviews.
Generally, people are in it for themselves in a professional network, but are also there as a guide to others.
In social networking, it's about sharing experiences and asking advice in more usual everyday things. Affiliation is more for the social in most people's lives. I believe that people who are more introvert benefit from the technology form of networking a lot more than extroverts, purely because extroverts want to get out there and be noticed and want to learn this way.
- What would your ideal network look like and why?
- What realistic things could you do to work towards developing your ideal network?
I can also ask around for advice from people who may have done a similar thing or plan to. Maybe I can team up with somebody to create the ideal network.
- What tools and methods do you need to use? What do you know about your current, and intended networks, and importantly, what do you not know?
I need to use my inquisitiveness in my professional networks and ask into peoples careers and people they may know.
There is definitely more that I don't know in my current and intended networks. For example, I don't know how many potential connections are out there for me. I don't believe I have many connections, but it's probably all hidden from me, just because I haven't gotten myself out there to try and find them.
I want to teach. I know that there must be some connections to other teachers or people associated with schools or dance schools.
'Keeeeep Blogging'
Friday, 29 November 2013
Task 2D Inquiry
I will start by considering the following things to find my themes/inquiry.
Music is my motivation in choreography and creativity in general. It inspires a lot of people, but for different things and in different ways.
Music is what makes me enthusiastic and the way it makes me feel to which I then go on to using it for my art=choreography. Whenever I hear a song that I really like, on the radio or in a shop or a website, I use the application; Shazam on my phone to find out what the song is and whom it is by. I then go on to researching more songs by this person to see if the song was just a fluke or one of many great songs that can influence my choreography. I found an album by Emmy Rossum a few years ago from hearing a clip of one of her songs called Slow me down on a random website (see YouTube clip). The song hit me instantly and I knew I wanted to choreograph to it. I went on to YouTube to find out whether the album was worth buying or whether it was the only good song on the album, and luckily it wasn't. Here is the link on Amazon where you can hear the clips of the songs, they are very unique: http://www.amazon.com/Inside-Out-Emmy-Rossum/dp/B000W7Y1LK Let me know what you think as I'm quite curious of other peoples' view of this rather fascinating album. I know that we are all different and have different incentives.
I admire my family very much. My mother and brother both have the same ways of thinking as I do. I often watch my mother searching for a piece of music she can use with her orchestra that is either unique, touching or dramatic. It is harder for her as classical music isn't played everywhere you go in society, so she really has to work hard to find something that strikes her attention, but when she finds one, it really is a good piece. Her orchestra stands out in the concerts. She loves her job even if most of the time it stresses her out. My brother, who is also a music and performing arts teacher, uses music as an influence for his school performances. I've been to his shows and they truly are unforgettable, and I promise that I'm not being biased. I hear parents' comment on how clever the performances were and how it'll be hard to beat the next year.
The things that make me sad and angry are how the performing arts business can be incredibly artificial. I think the thing that is very relevant to this is auditions. We have all been there. We walk into an audition and we notice the fake atmosphere all around. We also notice that the casting director has already pointed out who they want before the audition even begins. It's incredibly annoying and heartbreaking at the same time. We walk into an audition expecting to be judged on our performance and technique, yet even though this is what is stated by the casting director, we know deep down that it's all about image. The performing arts can be an incredibly harsh environment, but I think it's what makes most performers so strong when it comes to accepting criticism. These kind of auditions we can live with as we know that it is all about image, and it's obvious that they know exactly what they are looking for, and on that day, we just don't have the image that they want. As well as auditions, the artificial aura is everywhere from Television to Magazines. It's such a shame how 'mirage like' auditions are and how people get famous through lies and just knowing certain people. I am not a fan of shows that have terrible actors/actresses and are improvised. They just come across as very unbelievable. I admire Zooey Deschanel from New Girl. She said; "..If it doesn't feel true, I don't want to do it. Things that are too dramatic scare me. I think that's why I don't always fit into the world of Performing arts." http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html
I am very new to world of teaching, and I only teach on Saturdays but
there will be so many questions that will occur, and I will learn the
answers for the questions as I go along. My Mother has been a Primary
school teacher and has been teaching the Violin to four to sixteen year
old's for many years now. She has told me many times that 'Learning
to be a good teacher comes in time. Some methods work for others in the
way they teach a subject and how they discipline the students. By all
means try out these methods for yourself, but in the end you'll figure
out the best methods for you and most of them will just come from
experience.'
So after considering all of these things for my inquiry there are naturally many questions that occur such as:
I seem to talk about music, teaching and choreography the most. My ideas definitely come from these themes. I think about using illusions as a part of choreography. I can research different illusion objects and gadgets or even magicians and try to merge them into my way of choreography. I also think about Rock music. I haven't seen many dances that are performed to rock music. I love soft rock and some classic rock hits and they seem to get me up on my feet more than some pop songs. I have many friends who love dance and are into rock music and I'd love to attempt a dance routine to a song by Nickelback; When we stand together. It has quite a funky beat and I can visualize a powerful troupe dance to it.
I know that the deeper I go into this course the more ideas will emerge.
This is something I will reflect back on later in the course.
'Keeeeep Blogging'
Music is my motivation in choreography and creativity in general. It inspires a lot of people, but for different things and in different ways.
Music is what makes me enthusiastic and the way it makes me feel to which I then go on to using it for my art=choreography. Whenever I hear a song that I really like, on the radio or in a shop or a website, I use the application; Shazam on my phone to find out what the song is and whom it is by. I then go on to researching more songs by this person to see if the song was just a fluke or one of many great songs that can influence my choreography. I found an album by Emmy Rossum a few years ago from hearing a clip of one of her songs called Slow me down on a random website (see YouTube clip). The song hit me instantly and I knew I wanted to choreograph to it. I went on to YouTube to find out whether the album was worth buying or whether it was the only good song on the album, and luckily it wasn't. Here is the link on Amazon where you can hear the clips of the songs, they are very unique: http://www.amazon.com/Inside-Out-Emmy-Rossum/dp/B000W7Y1LK Let me know what you think as I'm quite curious of other peoples' view of this rather fascinating album. I know that we are all different and have different incentives.
I admire my family very much. My mother and brother both have the same ways of thinking as I do. I often watch my mother searching for a piece of music she can use with her orchestra that is either unique, touching or dramatic. It is harder for her as classical music isn't played everywhere you go in society, so she really has to work hard to find something that strikes her attention, but when she finds one, it really is a good piece. Her orchestra stands out in the concerts. She loves her job even if most of the time it stresses her out. My brother, who is also a music and performing arts teacher, uses music as an influence for his school performances. I've been to his shows and they truly are unforgettable, and I promise that I'm not being biased. I hear parents' comment on how clever the performances were and how it'll be hard to beat the next year.
The things that make me sad and angry are how the performing arts business can be incredibly artificial. I think the thing that is very relevant to this is auditions. We have all been there. We walk into an audition and we notice the fake atmosphere all around. We also notice that the casting director has already pointed out who they want before the audition even begins. It's incredibly annoying and heartbreaking at the same time. We walk into an audition expecting to be judged on our performance and technique, yet even though this is what is stated by the casting director, we know deep down that it's all about image. The performing arts can be an incredibly harsh environment, but I think it's what makes most performers so strong when it comes to accepting criticism. These kind of auditions we can live with as we know that it is all about image, and it's obvious that they know exactly what they are looking for, and on that day, we just don't have the image that they want. As well as auditions, the artificial aura is everywhere from Television to Magazines. It's such a shame how 'mirage like' auditions are and how people get famous through lies and just knowing certain people. I am not a fan of shows that have terrible actors/actresses and are improvised. They just come across as very unbelievable. I admire Zooey Deschanel from New Girl. She said; "..If it doesn't feel true, I don't want to do it. Things that are too dramatic scare me. I think that's why I don't always fit into the world of Performing arts." http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html
From that quote I get the impression that she is a realistic person, and I'm very sure she wouldn't do any show that wasn't comfortable such as these unrealistic, improvised TV shows. She inspires me because she is so normal and seems to take the fake performing arts world in her stride and carries on. I too don't always fit in to the performing arts world which is another reason why I greatly esteem her. I think it's why I strayed away from the performing side and have gone towards teaching. Teaching in schools and clubs is a lot more unpretentious and I want to inspire children to perform in a different way by being more down to earth. I've always wanted to teach anyway, but I always expected to teach dance with a more professional group of people rather than near beginners. It's the false atmosphere of stereotypical professionals that changed my mind on whom I wanted to teach. Deschanel stays clear of the stuff that is too dramatic and that makes her unhappy, and so do I.
Within teaching and choreography I can express my tacit knowledge and I can watch my efforts come to a remarkable achievement. I love these things in what I do, expressing my imagination through dance and teaching it, then seeing how it ends. I love to see the children improve and start realizing their own goals. Teaching is fulfilling (which is a lot more than I can say for my job in retail). I want to be an inspiration in dance choreography and how I go about it through music. I do believe that to perform or choreograph well, you must love every aspect of it; the music, how it makes you feel, how the movements flow, the expression, how it can captivate the viewers etc. Michael Jackson has been my inspiration since I was five years old. His music is captivating to me and his dancing is wonderful. It's not hard to see how much he enjoyed his dancing and his music. His choreography was brilliant, how every movement was like a side-kick to the different parts of the music and how the movements linked together so well. Check out his routine at the MTV Awards. This wouldn't have worked half as well without music.
His expression was so moving and you can feel the passion that he has for his work. So many people would have loved to work along side him, performing his genius work. I for one would have exulted in it! Just like he did, I want to share my passion. He will continue to be my inspiration even though his journey in this life came to an end.
There are many things that I don't understand like how choreographers can choreograph without music as inspiration. I'd love to swap minds with another choreographer for the day to see how they get inspired without music. To be honest, it isn't only music that can inspire me, it can be films too or books that I've read or even a painting which can spark an idea. But at the end of it all, I still turn to music as my top motivation. Perhaps I can try choreographing without music and just go with my initial idea? I know that I will find it incredibly hard to do so, but it could surprise me on how much I might enjoy it. Without giving it a go, I guess I would carry on being quite small minded on the matter. Both my Brother and I love to be creative, and we both share the same views on this. He says that our way of choreography can captivate most people whereas some other ways of choreography can only attract the odd number of people. I think if you have a very visual mind, and enjoy art (as in paintings or structures) the type of choreography that employs mainly shapes and designs will attract you the most. Whereas if you enjoy sounds and visual at the same time, the way in which I and many others choreograph will attract you more. It's so hard to say this with real assurance because I'm only going on what I believe. Perhaps I've got it right? Below is a video of some choreography without music.
When I'm deciding an appropriate response, I've always gone with approaches that have worked best for me in the past. With dance colleagues there's a lot more physical contact than there is in for example an office job or retail. It's weird to think that in different professions there are different, so-called appropriate ways to act with fellow colleagues. I couldn't say for sure if having innocent physical contact in the performing arts is right or wrong, it just seems okay. I've never been told or heard anybody else be told that it is weird or wrong, I think it's just generally a more comfortable environment for most in the performing arts profession.
Of course in the world of teaching, things are a lot more strict when it comes to responses and especially physical contact with students. This is something that has obviously changed dramatically over the years in education due to terrible events that have occurred. Employment in the teaching world has naturally become more strict too. Here is an example of why discipline in schools has changed. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-somerset-13292351
When it comes to disciplinary responses, in society I expect a high percentage of people that 'kick off' over some very unnecessary things. My approach in any situation is to stay calm. Every time that I've kept calm in any situation, the outcome is always a decent one. If I feel somebody is trying to give me a bad day just because they are, I keep smiling, and their efforts to try and put me down seem to decline.
So after considering all of these things for my inquiry there are naturally many questions that occur such as:
- How do bad choreographers seem to succeed?
- Why does the performing arts industry urge professionals to be pretentious?
- What other things are there that inspire choreography?
- What websites are there that could give more music ideas that suit my approach to choreography?
- What events have occurred that makes the act of discipline so weak nowadays in schools?
- Why is physical contact not as disciplined in the performing arts?
I know that the deeper I go into this course the more ideas will emerge.
This is something I will reflect back on later in the course.
'Keeeeep Blogging'
I'm
into sincerity in music and sincerity in art. If it doesn't feel true, I
don't want to do it. Things that are too dramatic scare me. I think
that's why I don't always fit into the world of performing arts.
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
I'm
into sincerity in music and sincerity in art. If it doesn't feel true, I
don't want to do it. Things that are too dramatic scare me. I think
that's why I don't always fit into the world of performing arts.
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
I'm
into sincerity in music and sincerity in art. If it doesn't feel true, I
don't want to do it. Things that are too dramatic scare me. I think
that's why I don't always fit into the world of performing arts.
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
I'm
into sincerity in music and sincerity in art. If it doesn't feel true, I
don't want to do it. Things that are too dramatic scare me. I think
that's why I don't always fit into the world of performing arts.
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
Read more at http://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/quotes/z/zooeydesch418384.html#GbQUPBUwOsHqMe4c.99
Wednesday, 20 November 2013
Task 2C Reflective Theory
This task has been very profound and I've spent a lot of time preparing. I've benefited greatly from doing so, and now I have a lot more understanding on Reflective Practice.
Firstly I like how Donald Schön describes Reflective Practice as; "..a dialogue of thinking and doing through which I become more skillful" (Schön, 1983 The Reflective Practitioner, p31). It narrates remarkably how I think and see reflection as in distinction to my uses of reflective practice in my work. I have many times watched videos of myself dancing and singing, and have been really struck on how awful parts of my voice sounded and have been extra critical on my dance technique and performance, hence, I go on to making myself look and sound better, improving on everything that I've seen and heard. I then video myself again, and go on to noticing different things that I weren't so aware of before, therefore rising the fact that I've fixed the parts that I noticed originally. My 'doing' and 'thinking'; reflecting back with a visual tool, has made me become more skillful in my dance technique, singing technique, performance and constructive critical thinking. In my possible future career in classroom teaching I will have to use 'Lesson planning'. This will be a tool for reflective practice. I believe that keeping a journal will be incredibly useful for any type of teaching, including my teaching position now, which I am now getting into.
Being a beginner in teaching, reflective practice is very necessary to building up my skills through mistakes and successes: "The successive portions of the reflective thought grow out of one another and support one another...each phase is a step from something to something.." (John Dewey, What is thought? 1910) Dewey sees reflective thought as a stream or flow. This applies to all of my reflective thinking and practice in my career. I experience a mistake; I correct it. I experience a success; I build on it. I build onto the success too far of which turns into a mistake; I correct it. I see a mistake; I correct it. It goes on and on. "Until the artist is satisfied in perception with what he is doing, he continues shaping and reshaping" (Dewey, Art as experience, 1934 p51) I cannot rest until I get my performance right, my singing right, my dancing technique up to standards or my skills in being a successful teacher.
"..Do something, think about what you did, come to conclusions about what you did and plan to try again." (Kolb, 1984) Referring to this, David Kolb came up with; Kolb's learning cycle.
I always enter the cycle at Doing/Having an experience. The learning cycle is what I use as kind of a template in my journal. It's become integrated in my mind now and I no longer need to look at it as my guide, although I have it there just in case my mind goes astray. The cycle will be a very constructive tool to refer to in my career in teaching. With lesson planning, I can use Kolb's cycle to be at my aide, and it will also be useful in my thoughts and actions during teaching which will be a form of reflection-in-action introduced by Schön in 1987. (refer to Reader 2, p7) Even in my performing, Kolb's learning cycle has been existent; when I worked in Israel, I had to perform in a very long skirt, and during the first lot of performances it would always make me trip up. I knew that I had to do something about it, so I firstly reflected on in, concluded from it and planned out what I'd learned or thought of doing. Therefore the result was me grabbing my skirt at certain points in the dance of which I remember my skirt being the most troublesome, and it worked well. I also added to this by tightening the skirt around my waist so that it wouldn't decline downwards so much. It is incredible how Kolb has made sense of a lot of things when it comes to learning. I've always just use the phrase 'you learn from your mistakes'. Well now I can use 'you learn from your mistakes and successes'. This knowledge has always been there subconsciously, somewhat, but it's become a fully conscious matter in my mind.
As a dance and music teacher I have had to use many tools, such as Cubase to cut and crop music and Itunes and Youtube to get music ideas. I think when using Cubase there isn't a lot of reflection going on as I know exactly how to use it, although, I remember there had been a bit of reflection at the start to remember where I got certain effects from and where I get different tools. Having a very musical family, thus having a very musical ear, cutting the music into the best places is very easy for me and the cuts always sound smooth.This relates to the psychologist Howard Gardners' belief in Multiple intelligences: Verbal linguistic, Logical-mathematical, Bodily-kinaesthetic, Musical, Interpersonal etc (refer to Reader 2, p6). I believe to be mainly Musical. I think I hold a few of the other intelligences too such as Bodily-kinaesthetic, Logical and Interpersonal, but I'm strongest in Musicality.
I believe that Gardner's theory is true to me and I'm sure to most people, but there are people who disagree with Gardner's theory such as Nathan Brody. He says that Gardners' "..list of intelligences is arbitrary," but I personally find it, as a non-psychologist, true, and even if Gardners theory is somewhat arbitruary to other psychologists, it makes sense to a lot of non-psychometric people like me. It's far from just being a belief such as religion, of which you relate to in more of an emotional way, this theory just makes sense. I'm definitely not linguistic. My intelligence is within my head. I am very much a person of 'tacit knowledge'. I am a very deep thinker, which I think in turn plays a part in why I am quite logical. I do try to use Jenifer Moon and Karen Osterman's views on the importance of turning tacit knowledge into verbal in some way. I try using metaphors a lot to try to get the right image to a person I may be trying to explain my tacit knowledge to. But even with that, there's a sort of resistance between the verbal and tacit knowledge and it becomes so difficult to attempt a swap over. "..we can know more than we can tell." (Polanyi, The tacit dimension, 1966 p4)
Twyla Tharp in The creative habit by Tharp and Reiter (refer to Reader 2, p11) talked about muscle memory and how it wouldn't be exactly impossible to turn movements into verbal, but once you start to learn something within your muscle memory (tacit knowledge) and then you are told the movements verbally, you'd start being very skeptical of your own knowledge of the dance. Like I've said about having a kinaesthetic and musical intelligence, as well as being a deep thinker and being non-linguistic, being told my dance routine step by step I would forget the whole thing, because then I'd be thinking too much about the dance instead of relying on what I've always relied on; the music, that helps me to remember certain steps, direction and flow. I can't verbally tell you how, it's partly an emotion, and it then becomes just muscle memory linked to the sounds that I know tacitly.
I can remember dances from when I was seven years old. If a piece of music comes onto the radio or pops into my head, my body just connects and remembers. I had to learn eight shows in two months for my job with P&O Cruises. I went home every night and listened to the music once over and then tried to remember the steps. When I went to bed I would go over the songs in my head and connect as many steps as possible. Then, the next day, I knew nearly the whole thing and better than some of the others who did the same thing as me. This also proves what Gardner says about having multiple intelligences. I was definitely more musical than my other dancing colleagues, therefore they relied more on muscle memory and what they had written down. We all possess different multiple intelligences and my colleagues all possessed some different ones to me.
"Noticing is about being aware of what is happening around us." (David Boud, Reflection in anticipation of events, 2001) Being aware of what is happening around me is something I am quite good at. I can notice when I've said or done something that urges a series of events around me. Sometimes it's bad and sometimes it's good. I learn from all the things that conclude in a bad event and I stop and think before I speak and I try to make things right. That is something I have learned through reflection. It also refers to when I've been in a dance troupe routine and I've regrettably ended up heading the wrong direction. If I hadn't noticed the other dancers going the other direction, I would have completely messed up the routine. I had to think quickly to make it less noticeable that I had made a mistake. This relates strongly to Reflection-in-action: "Reflection-in-action describes the process of working with noticing and intervening to interpret events and the effects of one's interventions."(Boud, Reflection in anticipation of events, 2001) I have had to use this method a lot and it's become quite natural, particularly in performing. Many times has my mind gone blank whilst performing and I've had to intervene by thinking up some other steps until my mind snaps back into action. As a dancer and choreographer, improvisation is something that's been improved over time, due to these mistakes. Like I mentioned earlier, reflection-in-action will be used in my future teaching career. If something isn't working to my lesson plan or if a type of discipline isn't effective, I would have to quickly notice these things and adapt accordingly to rectify the situation and therefore improve on my teaching skills. Reflection-on-action will be just as effective in my teaching career with the use of a journal; like I quoted earlier. I think that I'm stronger in reflection-in-action right now, but I know that in time my journal writing will improve, by keeping in mind of all the people that I've mentioned and what they've said. My offline reflection, resembling reflection-on-action by Robert Kottcamp (refer to Reader 2, p8) needs much development but I'm definitely progressing already.
Firstly I like how Donald Schön describes Reflective Practice as; "..a dialogue of thinking and doing through which I become more skillful" (Schön, 1983 The Reflective Practitioner, p31). It narrates remarkably how I think and see reflection as in distinction to my uses of reflective practice in my work. I have many times watched videos of myself dancing and singing, and have been really struck on how awful parts of my voice sounded and have been extra critical on my dance technique and performance, hence, I go on to making myself look and sound better, improving on everything that I've seen and heard. I then video myself again, and go on to noticing different things that I weren't so aware of before, therefore rising the fact that I've fixed the parts that I noticed originally. My 'doing' and 'thinking'; reflecting back with a visual tool, has made me become more skillful in my dance technique, singing technique, performance and constructive critical thinking. In my possible future career in classroom teaching I will have to use 'Lesson planning'. This will be a tool for reflective practice. I believe that keeping a journal will be incredibly useful for any type of teaching, including my teaching position now, which I am now getting into.
Being a beginner in teaching, reflective practice is very necessary to building up my skills through mistakes and successes: "The successive portions of the reflective thought grow out of one another and support one another...each phase is a step from something to something.." (John Dewey, What is thought? 1910) Dewey sees reflective thought as a stream or flow. This applies to all of my reflective thinking and practice in my career. I experience a mistake; I correct it. I experience a success; I build on it. I build onto the success too far of which turns into a mistake; I correct it. I see a mistake; I correct it. It goes on and on. "Until the artist is satisfied in perception with what he is doing, he continues shaping and reshaping" (Dewey, Art as experience, 1934 p51) I cannot rest until I get my performance right, my singing right, my dancing technique up to standards or my skills in being a successful teacher.
"..Do something, think about what you did, come to conclusions about what you did and plan to try again." (Kolb, 1984) Referring to this, David Kolb came up with; Kolb's learning cycle.
I always enter the cycle at Doing/Having an experience. The learning cycle is what I use as kind of a template in my journal. It's become integrated in my mind now and I no longer need to look at it as my guide, although I have it there just in case my mind goes astray. The cycle will be a very constructive tool to refer to in my career in teaching. With lesson planning, I can use Kolb's cycle to be at my aide, and it will also be useful in my thoughts and actions during teaching which will be a form of reflection-in-action introduced by Schön in 1987. (refer to Reader 2, p7) Even in my performing, Kolb's learning cycle has been existent; when I worked in Israel, I had to perform in a very long skirt, and during the first lot of performances it would always make me trip up. I knew that I had to do something about it, so I firstly reflected on in, concluded from it and planned out what I'd learned or thought of doing. Therefore the result was me grabbing my skirt at certain points in the dance of which I remember my skirt being the most troublesome, and it worked well. I also added to this by tightening the skirt around my waist so that it wouldn't decline downwards so much. It is incredible how Kolb has made sense of a lot of things when it comes to learning. I've always just use the phrase 'you learn from your mistakes'. Well now I can use 'you learn from your mistakes and successes'. This knowledge has always been there subconsciously, somewhat, but it's become a fully conscious matter in my mind.
As a dance and music teacher I have had to use many tools, such as Cubase to cut and crop music and Itunes and Youtube to get music ideas. I think when using Cubase there isn't a lot of reflection going on as I know exactly how to use it, although, I remember there had been a bit of reflection at the start to remember where I got certain effects from and where I get different tools. Having a very musical family, thus having a very musical ear, cutting the music into the best places is very easy for me and the cuts always sound smooth.This relates to the psychologist Howard Gardners' belief in Multiple intelligences: Verbal linguistic, Logical-mathematical, Bodily-kinaesthetic, Musical, Interpersonal etc (refer to Reader 2, p6). I believe to be mainly Musical. I think I hold a few of the other intelligences too such as Bodily-kinaesthetic, Logical and Interpersonal, but I'm strongest in Musicality.
I believe that Gardner's theory is true to me and I'm sure to most people, but there are people who disagree with Gardner's theory such as Nathan Brody. He says that Gardners' "..list of intelligences is arbitrary," but I personally find it, as a non-psychologist, true, and even if Gardners theory is somewhat arbitruary to other psychologists, it makes sense to a lot of non-psychometric people like me. It's far from just being a belief such as religion, of which you relate to in more of an emotional way, this theory just makes sense. I'm definitely not linguistic. My intelligence is within my head. I am very much a person of 'tacit knowledge'. I am a very deep thinker, which I think in turn plays a part in why I am quite logical. I do try to use Jenifer Moon and Karen Osterman's views on the importance of turning tacit knowledge into verbal in some way. I try using metaphors a lot to try to get the right image to a person I may be trying to explain my tacit knowledge to. But even with that, there's a sort of resistance between the verbal and tacit knowledge and it becomes so difficult to attempt a swap over. "..we can know more than we can tell." (Polanyi, The tacit dimension, 1966 p4)
Twyla Tharp in The creative habit by Tharp and Reiter (refer to Reader 2, p11) talked about muscle memory and how it wouldn't be exactly impossible to turn movements into verbal, but once you start to learn something within your muscle memory (tacit knowledge) and then you are told the movements verbally, you'd start being very skeptical of your own knowledge of the dance. Like I've said about having a kinaesthetic and musical intelligence, as well as being a deep thinker and being non-linguistic, being told my dance routine step by step I would forget the whole thing, because then I'd be thinking too much about the dance instead of relying on what I've always relied on; the music, that helps me to remember certain steps, direction and flow. I can't verbally tell you how, it's partly an emotion, and it then becomes just muscle memory linked to the sounds that I know tacitly.
I can remember dances from when I was seven years old. If a piece of music comes onto the radio or pops into my head, my body just connects and remembers. I had to learn eight shows in two months for my job with P&O Cruises. I went home every night and listened to the music once over and then tried to remember the steps. When I went to bed I would go over the songs in my head and connect as many steps as possible. Then, the next day, I knew nearly the whole thing and better than some of the others who did the same thing as me. This also proves what Gardner says about having multiple intelligences. I was definitely more musical than my other dancing colleagues, therefore they relied more on muscle memory and what they had written down. We all possess different multiple intelligences and my colleagues all possessed some different ones to me.
"Noticing is about being aware of what is happening around us." (David Boud, Reflection in anticipation of events, 2001) Being aware of what is happening around me is something I am quite good at. I can notice when I've said or done something that urges a series of events around me. Sometimes it's bad and sometimes it's good. I learn from all the things that conclude in a bad event and I stop and think before I speak and I try to make things right. That is something I have learned through reflection. It also refers to when I've been in a dance troupe routine and I've regrettably ended up heading the wrong direction. If I hadn't noticed the other dancers going the other direction, I would have completely messed up the routine. I had to think quickly to make it less noticeable that I had made a mistake. This relates strongly to Reflection-in-action: "Reflection-in-action describes the process of working with noticing and intervening to interpret events and the effects of one's interventions."(Boud, Reflection in anticipation of events, 2001) I have had to use this method a lot and it's become quite natural, particularly in performing. Many times has my mind gone blank whilst performing and I've had to intervene by thinking up some other steps until my mind snaps back into action. As a dancer and choreographer, improvisation is something that's been improved over time, due to these mistakes. Like I mentioned earlier, reflection-in-action will be used in my future teaching career. If something isn't working to my lesson plan or if a type of discipline isn't effective, I would have to quickly notice these things and adapt accordingly to rectify the situation and therefore improve on my teaching skills. Reflection-on-action will be just as effective in my teaching career with the use of a journal; like I quoted earlier. I think that I'm stronger in reflection-in-action right now, but I know that in time my journal writing will improve, by keeping in mind of all the people that I've mentioned and what they've said. My offline reflection, resembling reflection-on-action by Robert Kottcamp (refer to Reader 2, p8) needs much development but I'm definitely progressing already.
Monday, 18 November 2013
Task 2B Journal writing experience
After trying out all of the suggestions given on different writing styles and ways of thinking and reflecting, I have only adopted one more into what I originally did which was just using the Kolb's learning cycle as a base to write out my thoughts. I do believe that I enter on the 'having a concrete experience', so what I believe is the beginning of the cycle.
So, which one did I adopt? I adopted 'Another view'. I really enjoyed writing this way as it made me think as another person looking at me in my day. It made me more critical about myself (which already I am my own best teacher,) so this style advances my skills on this. It really helped me reflect better and made me point out parts of my day which I probably wouldn't have wanted to write down, mainly because I wouldn't have thought of them quite as important as perhaps another person would. It gives more depth in my reflective writing and definitely helps me a lot more.
In my original way of writing my journal I use a bit of 'Description', 'Evaluation' and 'What if?' anyway, so I don't feel comfortable just using these methods by themselves, I always merge them all, as it benefits me and my reflection greater than by themselves. This is how my mind works within my journal:
This has definitely been an experience and a successful one too. I'll probably be "journal-ing" about it tonight.
'Keeeeep blogging'
http://www.topappcharts.com/371886793/app-details-chronicle-for-ipad-a-personal-journal.php
So, which one did I adopt? I adopted 'Another view'. I really enjoyed writing this way as it made me think as another person looking at me in my day. It made me more critical about myself (which already I am my own best teacher,) so this style advances my skills on this. It really helped me reflect better and made me point out parts of my day which I probably wouldn't have wanted to write down, mainly because I wouldn't have thought of them quite as important as perhaps another person would. It gives more depth in my reflective writing and definitely helps me a lot more.
In my original way of writing my journal I use a bit of 'Description', 'Evaluation' and 'What if?' anyway, so I don't feel comfortable just using these methods by themselves, I always merge them all, as it benefits me and my reflection greater than by themselves. This is how my mind works within my journal:
- I write about what I did in as much detail as I can.
- I then write down what I think went wrong and what went right and what if?
- I then merge in from another point of view to be that extra bit critical on myself.
- I think of the things that might have worked better and would be better for the future.
- I then write down what I should try.
This has definitely been an experience and a successful one too. I'll probably be "journal-ing" about it tonight.
'Keeeeep blogging'
http://www.topappcharts.com/371886793/app-details-chronicle-for-ipad-a-personal-journal.php
Tuesday, 5 November 2013
Task 2B firstly...
Hi pepes...
So I've been having a think about which suggestions to try in this section, and I've decided on all except 'Description' and 'Graphs, charts and diagrams'.
I know that I've mentioned about being a visual learner, so you'd think that the diagrams options would appeal to me, but it doesn't. I think when it comes to my thoughts, I'd rather be pretty thorough about my day with my own writing and I can easily look up on this. I'm a real deep thinker. It's different from trying to learn something written down by somebody else, I mean with my journal; I wrote it, It was my idea to write it and it's my mind, therefore it's not hard to just sit down, read and recap on my own thoughts as it would be to read somebody else's. I might try the 'diagrams' option just out of curiosity. I may very well surprise myself. It's all about developing and learning after all.
Being a deep thinker and having quite a logic to my thinking, the 'description' suggestion didn't appeal to me either. It's just; this is it, this is where and this is when. It isn't profound enough for me to get on making improvements.
Emma Prices' blog helped me to think of something else to try. I will try using different coloured pens for different parts of my thinking. I think it could make it even easier to sum things up.
Will update in a week or so on how I got on and what my desired way of writing is.
'Keeeeep blogging'
So I've been having a think about which suggestions to try in this section, and I've decided on all except 'Description' and 'Graphs, charts and diagrams'.
I know that I've mentioned about being a visual learner, so you'd think that the diagrams options would appeal to me, but it doesn't. I think when it comes to my thoughts, I'd rather be pretty thorough about my day with my own writing and I can easily look up on this. I'm a real deep thinker. It's different from trying to learn something written down by somebody else, I mean with my journal; I wrote it, It was my idea to write it and it's my mind, therefore it's not hard to just sit down, read and recap on my own thoughts as it would be to read somebody else's. I might try the 'diagrams' option just out of curiosity. I may very well surprise myself. It's all about developing and learning after all.
Being a deep thinker and having quite a logic to my thinking, the 'description' suggestion didn't appeal to me either. It's just; this is it, this is where and this is when. It isn't profound enough for me to get on making improvements.
Emma Prices' blog helped me to think of something else to try. I will try using different coloured pens for different parts of my thinking. I think it could make it even easier to sum things up.
Will update in a week or so on how I got on and what my desired way of writing is.
'Keeeeep blogging'
Friday, 1 November 2013
Task 1C YouTube
Well here is my YouTube clip. I decided on a different approach to others on this task with the use of images and music etc. I find myself to be quite a creative person so I didn't want to neglect my creativity. :)
Do take a peek:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVDRJ_vg-n8
'Keeeeep Blogging'
Do take a peek:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aVDRJ_vg-n8
'Keeeeep Blogging'
Thursday, 31 October 2013
Task 2A Reflective Practice
Hi everyone.
So I started this task yesterday and read through Reader 2 quite thoroughly. It's definitely a lot to try and sink in.
I know that I am both a visual and kinaesthetic learner. When I was at school my reports would always say things such as; 'Kim is always in her own world' or 'Kimberley is often away with the fairies'. It's true that if I am just talked at or just reading something (no images or diagrams) I really find it difficult to take anything in, and my mind will then regularly wander off into the world of 'Kimmy.'... I need to be hands on to learn anything or see things as diagrams, photos or images.
Initially I thought this task would be very difficult for me, but, I can be very quick to think on the negatives before I move onto the positives. Being a 'deep thinker', this task should actually be a breeze for me. I can be quite logical and try to think things out on the spot, a.k.a Reflection IN Action, which I have learned is probably the most difficult way to reflect for most. But as a dancer it's something that has grown in me, from quickly thinking up an alternative movement when I've forgotten the original one, to using this skill in every day life. I know that as a teacher I have had to think of things on the spot when I have lost the children's attention or enthusiasm, so have had to quickly change from my original lesson plan to something a bit more spontaneous. Reflection ON action is something new but I know will be very beneficial as a teacher, and writing out a journal will be a great way to start.
I imagine it can be quite difficult to reflect on something that perhaps happened at the beginning of the day to then reflect on in the evening. Therefore whenever something happens that I think I will find useful to reflect on I will jot down in my notes on my phone. It will be strange to be writing out my thoughts rather than just keeping them in my mind or talking about them.
Boud's phrase; "Writing is a means of puzzling through", made me think that I've often found that I'm OK at puzzling through my thoughts just in my head, but, I believe that writing these thoughts down will be ten times more powerful than just hoping for the best in my head. I trust in Boud's wise words.
The other thing that is a little scary is what Polanyi said; 'We can know more than we can tell'.
As a choreographer I find it easier to just lie down and listen to the music I want to choreograph to. I close my eyes and can see what movements I can use and what would be effective. I could never express why these movements work, it's just a case of knowing more than we can tell. It just works!
Gardner mentions about different intelligences, and I believe that my strongest is definitely Musical. When either learning a routine or teaching it, it's always easier to listen to the song or piece of music first.
I too believe that I'm interpersonal, intrapersonal, bodily-kinaesthetic and a little bit logical-mathematical. I may write about parts in my day where I've used one or two of these intelligences and see how I can use them more for my own gain.
So with my journal I will start by referring to Kolb's cycle (pictured below) to help me on my way to reflecting accurately.
I will begin task 2B when I've gotten a little bit more used to writing my thoughts each evening.
This is something I definitely do not want to rush as I know how useful this will be in my professional life.
'Keeeeep blogging' xxx
So I started this task yesterday and read through Reader 2 quite thoroughly. It's definitely a lot to try and sink in.
I know that I am both a visual and kinaesthetic learner. When I was at school my reports would always say things such as; 'Kim is always in her own world' or 'Kimberley is often away with the fairies'. It's true that if I am just talked at or just reading something (no images or diagrams) I really find it difficult to take anything in, and my mind will then regularly wander off into the world of 'Kimmy.'... I need to be hands on to learn anything or see things as diagrams, photos or images.
Initially I thought this task would be very difficult for me, but, I can be very quick to think on the negatives before I move onto the positives. Being a 'deep thinker', this task should actually be a breeze for me. I can be quite logical and try to think things out on the spot, a.k.a Reflection IN Action, which I have learned is probably the most difficult way to reflect for most. But as a dancer it's something that has grown in me, from quickly thinking up an alternative movement when I've forgotten the original one, to using this skill in every day life. I know that as a teacher I have had to think of things on the spot when I have lost the children's attention or enthusiasm, so have had to quickly change from my original lesson plan to something a bit more spontaneous. Reflection ON action is something new but I know will be very beneficial as a teacher, and writing out a journal will be a great way to start.
I imagine it can be quite difficult to reflect on something that perhaps happened at the beginning of the day to then reflect on in the evening. Therefore whenever something happens that I think I will find useful to reflect on I will jot down in my notes on my phone. It will be strange to be writing out my thoughts rather than just keeping them in my mind or talking about them.
Boud's phrase; "Writing is a means of puzzling through", made me think that I've often found that I'm OK at puzzling through my thoughts just in my head, but, I believe that writing these thoughts down will be ten times more powerful than just hoping for the best in my head. I trust in Boud's wise words.
The other thing that is a little scary is what Polanyi said; 'We can know more than we can tell'.
As a choreographer I find it easier to just lie down and listen to the music I want to choreograph to. I close my eyes and can see what movements I can use and what would be effective. I could never express why these movements work, it's just a case of knowing more than we can tell. It just works!
Gardner mentions about different intelligences, and I believe that my strongest is definitely Musical. When either learning a routine or teaching it, it's always easier to listen to the song or piece of music first.
I too believe that I'm interpersonal, intrapersonal, bodily-kinaesthetic and a little bit logical-mathematical. I may write about parts in my day where I've used one or two of these intelligences and see how I can use them more for my own gain.
So with my journal I will start by referring to Kolb's cycle (pictured below) to help me on my way to reflecting accurately.
I will begin task 2B when I've gotten a little bit more used to writing my thoughts each evening.
This is something I definitely do not want to rush as I know how useful this will be in my professional life.
'Keeeeep blogging' xxx
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)